July 15, 1997 in Miami Beach. Andrew is walking down the street. He passes a few cops before getting to the gates of Gianni’s mansion. He crosses the street and shoots Gianni. That night Andrew is still in town. He breaks into a houseboat and pops open some champagne to watch the news coverage about the murder. He finds out that he’s a suspect.
He takes his champagne to the balcony and watches helicopters and listens to the sirens. In Tampa, Lee Miglin’s widow has a knock on her door. It’s the FBI. They tell her that her husband’s murder is linked to Versace’s. She’s pissed. It’s been two months. How have they not caught him yet? She asks where he is now and they tell her Andrew evaded capture.
They don’t think it’s safe that she stay in Florida and have a flight waiting for her. She isn’t willing to miss a broadcast though. She goes to the studio. Andrew wakes up the next day to coverage about himself. He sees Mrs. Miglin on the news as well before getting dressed and heading out. He goes downtown and steals a purse to get some car keys.
As he drives out of the city, he hits traffic because of a road block. Cops are searching cars. He turns around and barks a few blocks away. He’s going over a map when an older man finds him. Andrew asks for directions but the guy tells him that all the roads off the island are blocked. Andrew takes off pretty quick after that. He ditches the car.
Andrew’s mother is watching the coverage as well when agents show up at her door. Andrew goes back to the houseboat he was in the night before to regroup. His friend gets picked up by the FBI and questioned about Andrew’s whereabouts. He talks about how the gays usually play by the books and stay quiet. Andrew isn’t like that though.
He’s not hiding. He wants to be seen. Andrew hears to the marina and breaks onto a boat. He’s reading a map when he hears someone yelling. He ducks into the bathroom and pulls out his gun. The woman is aboard the boat checking. She pushes on the bathroom door and he slams it shut. She runs away.
Once she’s gone, Andrew gets off the boat and heads back to the houseboat. With his binoculars, he sees that the FBI is talking to the woman in the marina. He hears Lizzie make a plea for him to surrender on tv. News coverage is wall to wall. They are talking about Jeff and David and how Andrew was linked to them.
David’s father is interviewed. He is adamant that David was a good man. Andrew is running out of options. He’s out of food and starts picking through his own garbage. It yields nothing so he turns to dog food. He can’t keep it down though. He turns to the tv and Mrs. Miglin is talking about how rough it was growing up after her father died.
It’s a touching story. Afterward, Andrew goes to a pay phone and calls Modesto in the Philippines. It seems that he has been doing quite a few phone interviews, and charging for them. He tells Andrew he will fly back and help him escape. Modesto asks for the particulars on where Andrew is, then tells him to pack and meet him in the same spot the next night.
Andrew goes back to the houseboat and does just that. The next night, Andrew is getting ready to head out. He walks outside and then goes back in and hears his father. He’s doing an interview on tv and lying through the whole thing. He never flew to the States. Andrew is pissed. He shoots the tv.
July 22. The day of Gianni’s funeral. Donatella and Antonio talk about being heartbroken. She asks him what he plans to do. He wants to stay in one of the houses to be close to Gianni but the board owns them. She tells him to go to Lake Como for a while and then start fresh. There’s nothing she can do. Andrew can stomach the dog food now.
He’s got facial hair and catches a cockroach under a glass. He’s examining it when he hears the news. It’s coverage of Gianni’s funeral. Andrew hooks it up to a projector and watches it. At the funeral, Antonio is left out of the list of loved ones left behind. He’s upset. Andrew shaves his head. A man gets a call tipping him off about a burglary at a houseboat.
The guy goes to investigate. He announces himself and says that he’s armed. When he gets to the living room, a shot is fired at him. He takes off. Andrew sees on the news that police are swarming the houseboat. He stays holed up inside. Cops know so they cut the power. Andrew puts the gun in his mouth and pulls the trigger.
Years earlier, Andrew and Gianni are on stage. Andrew talks about being inspired and working for Gianni. He leans in and kisses him. Gianni shuts him down though. He tells him that it’s not because he’s not interested but because he has other things to do. The cops find Andrew’s body.
Marilyn Miglin finds out Andrew is dead. She’s not upset about it. She tells someone about all the letters that she has gotten about Lee since his death. The letters keep him alive. Donatella is beating herself up because she ignored the last call she got from Gianni. They had talked earlier in the day and she was annoyed with him so when he called back she ignored it.
Antonio pours a whole bottle of pills onto a plate. Donatella leaves the house in the rain. Antonio swallows all the pills and starts drinking wine to wash them down. Donatella gets to her house and lights candles for Gianni. The nameplate is put at a gravesite. A maid finds Antonio. He’s still alive. Donatella cries. The nameplate is for Andrew.
I don’t know why but I really expected this to be a lot more about Versace and not like… a profile of Andrew’s crimes. I don’t know. There was never really a payoff on this. Why was he doing this? Was he sick? What came next? I liked it but it’s not what I expected.